Nashville Area Homes is owned by Candie and Mike Worsham, licensed Tennessee brokers who have worked in Middle Tennessee real estate for more than 30 years.
Start with this one: “Tell me about a time you advised a seller to change their price, and what happened.” The answer shows how the agent thinks, how they use evidence, and whether they will give you honest advice when it counts.
There are plenty of questions to ask a realtor when selling your home, and you can fit a dozen good ones into a listing interview. This one tells you the most and takes about two minutes. Below is why it works, what a good answer sounds like, and what to ask next.
Table of Contents

Why is this the one question to ask a realtor before you sell?
Because it asks for judgment, and judgment is what you are hiring.
Agreeing with a seller is easy. It feels good in the room and costs nothing. Real advice sometimes sounds like, “I know what you hoped for, and here is what the evidence shows.” That is harder to say, and it is the part of the job that protects you.
I’ve learned that telling a client the truth is really more important than telling them what they want to hear. After decades in this business, there is no greater compliment than hearing, “Call Candie, she’ll tell you the truth.” This question lets you find out whether an agent works that way before you sign anything.
What does a good answer sound like?
Listen for four things.
- A specific situation. Not “I always give honest advice,” but an actual home, an actual conversation and what was said.
- Evidence. Comparable sales, condition, location, timing. A reason you can check, not a feeling.
- Respect for the seller. The agent explained the advice, and the seller made the decision.
- What happened next. An agent who can tell you how it turned out, good or not so good, is being straight with you.
If the agent needs a moment to think, give it to them. A thoughtful answer beats a quick one. And a general answer tells you something too. It tells you what you will hear when your own house is the one being priced.
Why does the price conversation matter so much?
The first weeks on the market are the biggest weeks your home will have.
A fresh listing gets its largest exposure the day it appears. Buyers who have looked at everything available are waiting for something new, and they check new listings first. An overpriced home can lose its strongest opportunity in those first weeks.
Here is what I have seen. I’ve seen three and four bedroom houses priced like five bedroom houses, and no one even looks at them. Then comes a price reduction. The same buyers see the listing again and wonder what is wrong with the home and why it didn’t sell the first time. After that, the listing has a hard time winning back its first impression.
The lowest price does not always win. The right price on day one gives you the most buyers to choose from. We go deeper in Starting High to Leave Room to Negotiate Can Backfire.
An agent who has talked a seller through a pricing decision has practiced the conversation you will need to have.
Which questions to ask a realtor when selling your home cover the price?
Once you have heard their story, ask about your own house.
- Which comparable sales did you use, and why do they fit my home?
- Which sales did you leave out?
- What would a buyer like about my house, and what might give them pause?
- If an offer comes in lower than we hoped, how will we decide what to do?
Pay attention to whether the agent explains or just announces. A number with reasons behind it is something you can weigh. A number with no reasons is a guess.
Bring any online estimate you have seen. Apps cannot see your kitchen, your lot or the road behind your fence. A good agent will go through the estimate with you instead of brushing it off. We explain more in What a Home Value Estimate From an App Cannot Tell You and Why Comparable Sale Does Not Mean What You Think It Means.
I’ve learned the highest price isn’t always the best offer.
What should you ask about local knowledge?
Ask the agent to describe your street, not only your neighborhood.
Where does traffic back up? What is confirmed about the area, and what is only talk? If the school assignment matters to you, how would the agent confirm it? The right answer points you to the school district’s own lookup for your exact address. Buyers test local knowledge the minute they walk in, and your agent should pass the same test before you list.
Local knowledge matters. Our post on what local knowledge actually means when you sell in Nashville has more.
What should you ask about marketing and communication?
Ask to see what your listing will look like before it goes live. A list of plans is not the same thing.
- Who takes the photos, and who writes the description?
- Where will the home be shown to buyers?
- What happens in the first week, and what changes if showings are slow?
- How often will I hear from you, and by phone, text or email?
Communication can save a transaction. Small inspection issues can become large negotiation problems when they aren’t handled correctly. Ask how the agent prepares sellers for an inspection and what happens when a buyer asks for repairs. Our post on what a home inspection report actually protects you from helps you get ready.
What should you ask about cost and the contract?
Ask how the agent is paid, what that payment covers and what can be negotiated. Ask how long the listing agreement runs and how it can end if the service is not what you were promised. Ask what costs you could owe if the home does not sell.
Read the agreement before you sign, and ask about anything that is unclear. It should all be in writing for you to review at your own pace. A clear, unhurried answer to these questions is a good sign.
How many agents should you talk to?
Two or three is enough for most sellers. Ask each to come to your house. An agent who has stood in your living room can tell you things a phone call cannot. Ask each the same questions, starting with the one above, and lay the answers side by side.
You can also check any agent’s license on the Tennessee Real Estate Commission website before you meet.
Our full walkthrough, including what to bring, is in How to Choose a Listing Agent Before You Sign. If you are getting ready to sell, you are welcome to try these questions on us. Ask us the hard version. Call (615) 208-3313 or contact us.
Common questions
What is the best question to ask a realtor when selling your home?
Ask for a time they advised a seller to change their price, and what happened. The answer shows whether the agent uses evidence, explains their reasoning and gives honest advice when it is not the easy thing to say.
How many questions should I ask in a listing interview?
You do not need a long list. Five or six good questions about pricing, marketing, communication and the contract will tell you more than twenty general ones. Write them down and ask every agent the same ones.
What should a good answer to the pricing question include?
A specific home or situation, the evidence behind the advice and what happened afterward. Comparable sales, condition and timing are the kinds of reasons to listen for. A general answer with no example is worth noting.
Should I choose the agent who recommends the highest price?
Not for that reason alone. A price should come with comparable sales and clear reasons. A high number with nothing behind it can cost you the first weeks of buyer attention, when a new listing gets the most views.
Can I interview Candie and Mike Worsham?
Yes, and we welcome it. Ask us these questions and the hard versions of them. Call (615) 208-3313 or contact us to set up a time.
Candie Worsham, Nashville Area Homes. 3102 West End Ave, Suite 400, Nashville, TN 37203.
General information note: This article is general information in our own words. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, and it is not a recommendation of any neighborhood, school or district. Confirm school assignment with the school district. Nashville Area Homes follows federal and Tennessee fair housing law.
