How to Choose a Listing Agent: What to Ask Before You Sign
How to choose a listing agent starts with an interview at your house. This is the Nashville Area Homes guide to interviewing a listing agent. Nashville Area Homes is owned by Candie and Mike Worsham, licensed Tennessee brokers who have worked in Middle Tennessee real estate for more than 30 years.
The short answer: meet at least two agents at your house, ask each one how they would price and market your home and why, and hire the one who gives you specific answers, even when those answers are not the ones you hoped for. You are hiring judgment, not agreement.
Most sellers spend more time researching a refrigerator than they do choosing the person who will manage the biggest financial transaction of their year. That is not a knock on sellers. The process just gets rushed. Here is what a real interview sounds like.
Table of Contents

Why does the interview matter so much?
The first weeks on the market matter more than any other stretch of the listing. A fresh listing gets its largest exposure on day one. Buyers who are already tired of the homes they have seen are waiting for something new, and they look at new listings first.
In Candie’s experience, a house that starts too high and comes down later loses those first buyers, and the price cut that follows makes buyers ask what is wrong with the home. The agent you choose decides how that first stretch goes, which is why the interview is worth an afternoon.
You can read more on that in Starting High to Leave Room to Negotiate Can Backfire.
How to choose a listing agent: who should you interview?
Meet two or three agents. Ask each to come to the house, not to talk on the phone. An agent who has stood in your living room can tell you what buyers will like and what will worry them. A price quoted from the driveway skips what only the inside of your home can tell.
Referrals from people you trust are a good place to start. So is an agent who has recently sold homes near yours. Ask to see those sales. You can also check any agent’s license with the Tennessee Real Estate Commission.
What should you ask first about your house?
Start with the house, not the price. Before an agent says a number, ask them to talk about your property.
- What would buyers like about it?
- What would concern them?
- Which homes would they compare it to, and where does that comparison break down?
An agent who answers this specifically has thought about your house. A generic answer about the market in general means they have not.
Do they know your street, or just your neighborhood?
Ask whether they have walked your street at different times of day. Ask what is confirmed about the area and what is just neighborhood talk. A subdivision-level answer is not the same as a street-level answer. The difference shows up in how a home gets priced and marketed.
Local knowledge is a real skill. We wrote about what it looks like in What Local Knowledge Actually Means When You Are Selling in Nashville.
How will they decide the price?
Ask the agent to explain, not just state, the price they recommend. Ask which comparable sales they used and why those sales fit. Ask which sales they left out and why.
Bring any online estimate you have seen. Apps do not know your kitchen, your lot, or the road behind your fence. A good agent will walk you through why an estimate is off, in either direction, instead of waving it away. See What a Home Value Estimate From an App Cannot Tell You and Why Comparable Sale Does Not Mean What You Think It Means.
The highest number is not always the best one. A high price can win the listing and lose the sale, so ask what supports it.
What is the one question that reveals the most?
Ask for an example of a time they advised a seller against the seller’s own preferred price.
Anyone can agree with you at the kitchen table. Agreement is easy and costs the agent nothing. You are hiring judgment, and judgment sometimes means hearing something you do not want to hear. The agent who has done this before, and can tell you what happened, is telling you how they will treat you.
Candie says the best compliment she can get is hearing, “Call Candie, she’ll tell you the truth.” Telling a client the truth matters more than telling them what they want to hear. Listen for that in every agent you meet.
How will they market your home?
Ask to see what the listing will look like, not just a list of things they plan to do. Ask who takes the photos, who writes the description, and where the listing will appear. Ask what happens in the first week and what they will change if the home does not get showings.
Ask how often you will hear from them and how. A plan with no schedule for updates tends to turn into silence.
What should you ask about cost and the contract?
Ask how they are paid, what that covers, and what is negotiable. Ask what costs you may owe if the home does not sell. Ask how long the listing agreement runs and how you can end it if the service falls short. Read the agreement before you sign it, and ask questions about anything you do not understand.
An agent who answers these questions clearly and without hurry is a good sign.
How do they handle inspections and negotiation?
A small inspection issue can turn into a large negotiation problem if it is handled poorly. Ask how the agent prepares sellers for inspections and what they do when a buyer asks for repairs. Ask how they communicate when an offer comes in. Good communication can save a deal. We cover what a report is really for in What a Home Inspection Report Actually Protects You From.
What should you bring to the interview?
- Any online estimate you have seen.
- A list of what you have updated or repaired, with dates.
- Your questions about comparable sales near you.
- The date you hope to be moved out by, and why.
What are the warning signs?
- A price with no explanation behind it.
- Pressure to sign today.
- Vague answers about marketing.
- No questions about you, your timeline, or your goals.
- Agreement with everything you say, with no pushback on anything.
Common questions
How many agents should I interview before I list?
Two or three is enough for most sellers. Meet them at your house so they can see what they would be selling.
What is the most important question to ask a listing agent?
Ask for a time they advised a seller against the seller’s preferred price. The answer shows whether they will give you honest advice.
Should I pick the agent who suggests the highest price?
Not for that reason alone. A price should come with comparable sales and a reason. A high number with no support can cost you the first weeks of buyer attention.
What should I ask about the commission?
Ask how the agent is paid, what that covers, and what is negotiable. Get the answer in writing in the listing agreement.
Can I interview Candie and Mike?
Yes. We welcome it. Ask us the hard version of these questions. That is how we would want a seller to choose us. Call (615) 208-3313 or contact us.
Candie Worsham, Nashville Area Homes. 3102 West End Ave, Suite 400, Nashville, TN 37203.