PRICING YOUR HOME

What Comps in Real Estate Really Are and How Agents Pick Them

Comps in real estate are recent sales of homes similar enough to yours that they help show what buyers will pay for yours. Agents pick comps by matching location, size, age, condition and features, then adjusting for the differences. A comp doesn’t hand you a price. It hands you a place to start asking questions.

Nashville Area Homes is owned by Candie and Mike Worsham, licensed Tennessee brokers with more than 30 years in Middle Tennessee real estate. “Comparable sale” sounds like math, like a settled fact. On its own it explains very little, and treating it as a finished answer is one of the most common pricing mistakes Candie sees.

Nashville Area Homes conference room where we walk sellers through comps in real estate

What are comps in real estate?

A comp is a home that sold recently and resembles yours. You will also hear it called a comparable sale. Buyers don’t pay in a vacuum. They pay relative to what else they could have bought, and a sold home shows what a real buyer and a real seller agreed to.

That’s why closed sales matter. A listing price is a hope. A closed sale is a fact. But a fact about a different house only helps if the two houses are truly alike.

How do agents choose comps?

A good agent filters first and thinks second. The filters usually cover location, size, age and style, lot, and timing.

For location, close by is the start, and a similar setting matters too. A sale on a street with heavy traffic and a sale on a quiet cul-de-sac don’t always compare. For size, look at square footage, bedrooms and bathrooms in a similar range. For age and style, homes built in a similar era or to a similar standard line up best. The lot counts as well: its size, its shape and how usable the yard is. Timing is the last filter. The more recent the sale the better, and in a market that’s moving, the newest sales count most.

Then the thinking starts. That part is where experience pays, and it’s why local knowledge matters. We explain what that looks like in What Local Knowledge Actually Means When You Are Selling in Nashville.

What does a comp have to answer?

A comp has to hold up against questions like these. Was the other house renovated, or original? Did it come with a garage, a finished basement or a pool? Did it sell with seller concessions that lowered the effective price? What was the market doing when the contract was signed, as opposed to when it closed?

Two houses can sit four doors apart and answer those questions very differently. The one that lines up on paper isn’t always the one that lines up in person.

What does it mean to adjust a comp?

Adjusting means accounting for what’s different. If the comp has a finished basement and your home doesn’t, the comp’s price includes value your home lacks. If your home has a newer roof, you have something the comp doesn’t.

Agents make these adjustments with judgment, and different agents will make them differently. That’s no flaw. It’s the reason to ask to see the reasoning and not only the result. A pricing opinion that can’t explain its adjustments is a guess in a nice font.

Try a simple test. Pick one comp and ask what you’d have to add or subtract to make it match your home. If the answer comes quickly and specifically, the agent has done the work. If the answer is a shrug, ask again. You’re entitled to see how the number was built, and a good agent will enjoy showing you.

How does Candie build a price?

In Candie’s own words: “I start with closed sales, because those are facts. Then I look at what’s actively competing with your home right now, because that’s who a buyer will actually compare you to. Then I look at what buyers walked away from recently, and why, because that tells you where the ceiling really is.”

That last step is the one people skip. A home that sat and never sold, or one that was withdrawn, tells you something a closed sale can’t. It shows you where buyers stopped. A single number from a single comp skips almost all of that work.

What question separates analysis from a guess?

Ask your agent to show you one comparable sale that supports their suggested price and one that challenges it.

If they can only show the first kind, you’re getting a sales pitch and no pricing analysis. Every honest pricing opinion has a sale in it that argues the other way. Naming it tells you the agent has looked at the whole picture. Candie puts it simply: a comp is a question, not an answer.

We list more questions worth asking in How to Choose a Listing Agent and in The One Question Every Seller Should Ask Before Hiring an Agent.

Where do online estimates fit in?

An app can run a comparison in seconds, but it works from records and a model, and it hasn’t been inside your home. We cover what it can and can’t see in What a Home Value Estimate From an App Cannot Tell You.

Once you have a price you can defend, don’t pad it. See Starting High to Leave Room to Negotiate Can Backfire. And if a listing has already been on the market, Why a Price Reduction Needs a Reason, Not Just a Number shows how comps guide the next move.

Buyers use comps too. When an offer comes in, the price is only part of what it says, and we cover the rest in What an Offer Really Tells You Beyond the Number.

Common questions

How many comparable sales should an agent use?

There’s no magic count. Use enough to see a pattern and few enough that each one is truly similar. Quality matters more than quantity. Ask which sales were left out and why.

How recent should a comparable sale be?

The more recent, the better, because buyers respond to the market as it is now. In a market that’s changing, older sales deserve less weight. Your agent should be able to explain how much weight each sale got.

Do homes for sale now count as comps?

Closed sales are the facts, and the Davidson County Assessor of Property publishes property and sales records you can look up yourself. The homes currently for sale are your competition. A buyer will compare your home to them this week. A solid pricing opinion looks at both.

Can a home across town be a good comp?

Sometimes, if the home is similar in other ways. Nearby sales usually speak more directly to what a buyer in your location will pay, so your agent should explain why a farther sale was included.

Can I see the comps behind a price?

Yes, and you should. Ask for the sales, the reasoning and the adjustments. Candie and Mike are glad to show you theirs. Call (615) 208-3313 or contact us.

Candie Worsham, Nashville Area Homes. 3102 West End Ave, Suite 400, Nashville, TN 37203.

General information note: This article is general information in our own words. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, and it is not a recommendation of any neighborhood, school or district. Confirm school assignment with the school district. Nashville Area Homes follows federal and Tennessee fair housing law.

POSTED IN: Pricing Your Home